Unlocking Mere Christianity (Week 3): What Christians Don’t Believe About Evil and Rival Gods

3 hours ago
6 min read

Last week, we closed out Book 1 with a staggering problem. C.S. Lewis laid down a bulletproof argument that an objective moral law exists, which points directly to an ultimate Lawgiver. He showed that this Maker has a clear preference for good conduct, and because we constantly break His law, we have inadvertently made ourselves His enemies.

Tonight, we step into Book 2: What Christians Believe. But before Lewis tells us what Christians do believe, he takes a fascinating detour into what Christians don't believe. He tackles the rival conceptions of God, the real origin of evil, and the shocking claims of Jesus.

If you need a copy of the handouts to follow along with our live streams,

In case you missed it, here is Week 2's handout

Who Was C.S. Lewis? The Reluctant Convert Behind Mere Christianity

When discussing world religions, many people assume that Christians must take a completely narrow approach. But Lewis points out a surprising truth right out of the gate: Christians do not need to believe that all other religions are a complete mistake.

If you are an atheist, you have to believe that the vast majority of the human race has been dead wrong about the foundational nature of reality since the beginning of time. You have to believe there is absolutely zero truth in any divine reality.

A Christian, however, is free to take a much more liberal view. We believe that where other religions agree with us, they contain genuine elements of truth. It is only when they make exclusive, conflicting claims that we say Christianity is right and they are wrong.

Mere Christianity Book 1 Chapter 1 Summary: The Law of Human Nature

As Lewis splits the religious world into different camps, he highlights two radically different views of God:

1. The Pantheist View (God is "In" Creation)

Pantheists believe God is animated through the universe, or that God is the universe itself. To them, if the universe didn't exist, God wouldn't exist. Because they view everything as a part of God, they believe moral categories like "good" and "evil" are just human illusions. From their divine perspective, nothing is truly right or wrong, and God has no personal preferences.

2. The Christian View (God "Made" Creation)

Christianity claims that God is a separate Maker who invented and created the heavens and the earth. Much like an artist who stands distinct from the canvas they just painted, God remains entirely independent from what He made. Because God is fundamentally good, it means some things in this universe are genuinely wrong, broken, and completely contrary to His will.

The Paradox of Calling the Universe Unjust

This creates the ultimate theological question: If a good God made the world, why has it gone so horribly wrong?

Lewis admits that as an atheist, he used this exact argument to reject God. He argued that the universe seemed too cruel and unjust to have an intelligent creator. But then he stopped to look at the logic of his own objection. Where did he get his idea of "just" and "unjust" in the first place?

To explain this paradox, Lewis relies on three vivid analogies:

The Straight Line: A man does not call a line crooked unless he has some absolute concept of a straight line.
The Wet Fish: A fish never complains about the sea being wet. It only feels wet because the fish is designed for a different kind of existence. If we were native to a completely meaningless universe, we would never discover that it was meaningless.
The Blind Man (No Eyes): If the universe had no light, and creatures were born with no eyes, we would never know that darkness existed. The word "dark" would have no meaning.

Our very ability to recognize that the world is cruel and unjust proves that we are appealing to a real standard of perfection that is higher and further back than ourselves. Therefore, atheism is simply too simple!

Mere Christianity Chapter 2 Breakdown: Objective Morality vs. Instincts

In Chapter 2 (The Invasion), Lewis deals with Dualism—the belief that the universe is a battlefield between two equal, independent cosmic powers: one good and one bad.

Lewis notes that Dualism is a manly, preferences-shattering view, but it falls apart under closer logical scrutiny. For a "Bad Power" to actively love badness for its own sake, it must possess intelligence, will, and desires. But intelligence, will, and existence are inherently good things. Therefore, the Bad Power is forced to borrow the very materials of goodness from its rival just to operate!

Evil is a Parasite

This reveals the true nature of evil: nothing is evil unto itself. Evil does not have an independent, creative existence. It cannot create anything original; it can only twist, make crooked, corrupt, misuse, and pervert what is already fundamentally good. Moral failure is simply the pursuit of a good thing by the wrong means.

   THE CHRISTIAN METAPHOR OF REALITY:
   ┌────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
   │ Evil is not an equal rival; it is a rebel.             │
   ├────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┤
   │ The universe is currently enemy-occupied territory.    │
   ├────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┤
   │ Jesus is the rightful King landing in disguise.        │
   └────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘

The story of Christianity is not a duel between equals; it is the account of a civil war. The Dark Power is a created being that fell through rebellion against the true God. We are living in enemy-occupied territory, and when we gather for discipleship, praise, and worship, we are participating in a massive campaign of sabotage and liberation!

The Shocking Alternative: The Fuel of Free Will

In Chapter 3, Lewis addresses why a good God would allow his creatures to rebel in the first place. The answer is Free Will.

If a creature is free to be good (like a child choosing to tidy up their room), it must also be completely free to be bad (choosing to leave it a mess). Free will makes evil possible, but it is also the only thing that makes any love, goodness, or joy worth having. God thought the relationship was worth the risk.

The Blueprint of Creation

Lewis sets up a brilliant sliding scale regarding the risk of creation:

A Cow: Very little capacity for good or evil.
A Dog: Slightly more capacity.
A Child / Ordinary Man: Highly capable of profound goodness or dynamic failure.
A Man of Genius: Massive capacity to build or destroy.
A Superhuman Spirit: The highest capacity of all.

The better the raw materials of a creature—the more clever, stronger, and freer it is—the more it can go spectacularly right, or horribly, catastrophically wrong. Satan was a superhuman spirit who fell because of pride, trying to put himself first and find happiness apart from his Creator.

Humans are designed to "run" on God as our proper fuel. Trying to find peace, security, and happiness outside of Him is like trying to run a gasoline car on water. It inevitably fails, which explains the constant cycle of achievement and collapse throughout human history.

What Did God Do to Rescue Us?

To prevent our total self-destruction, God executed a three-fold rescue plan throughout history:

Conscience: He left us with an internal sense of right and wrong that we can never quite get rid of.
Good Dreams: He scattered beautiful stories throughout ancient cultures about a saving God who dies and comes back to life.
A Particular People: He selected one specific, peculiar group of people (the Jews) and spent centuries hammering into their heads that there is only one God who deeply cares about right conduct.

Then comes the real shock of history. Out of this specific group of people, a man turns up claiming to do things only God can do. He heals the sick, commands storms, and multiplies food.

But most shockingly of all, He forgives sins. When Jesus tells a paralyzed man or a sinful woman, "Your sins are forgiven," He doesn't consult the people who were actually hurt by their actions. This behavior only makes logical sense if Jesus is God Himself—the One who is chiefly hurt by every single sin committed in human history.

Mere Christianity Discussion Questions & Study Guide (Week 3 Review)

Take time to process these deep questions from this week's study to prepare your mind:

The Atheist's Burden: How does it change your perspective to realize that Christians can accept elements of truth in other world religions, while atheists must claim the entire world has been entirely wrong?
The Parasite of Evil: If nothing is evil unto itself, and evil is simply a twisted perversion of an original good, how does that change the way you fight temptation and recognize the real enemy in your daily life?
The Rightful King: When you participate in worship, prayer, and small group study, do you view it as passive attendance, or do you view it as an active act of "sabotage" against the dark powers occupying this world?

Looking Ahead: Get Ready for Week 4!

Next Tuesday night at 7:00 PM MST, join me live as we close out Book 2 together! We will be streaming simultaneously across our YouTube, Facebook, and TikTok channels (@BibleN3rd). Grab your book, read Book 2, Chapters 4–5, and let's get ready to unpack the mechanics of the Atonement!

This study and all associated digital downloads are completely free. However, if this content is helping you grow and you feel led to partner with me, you can drop a donation via my spotFund link below to support my upcoming mission trip back to Israel. Every contribution helps fund the work on the ground.

Below is your preview study handout for next week. Print it out, dig into the text, and let's keep n3rd-ing out together!